Optical Brightener and Bleach are two different chemicals, and although they both make the material look whiter, they work and work in different applications. Understanding the differences and similarities between these two substances is crucial for their effective use and safety.This article will explore in detail the definition of optical brightener, mechanism of action, application field and differences from bleach.
Optical brighteners, or fluorescent whitening agents (FWAs), are a class of chemicals designed to enhance the brightness and whiteness of materials. These compounds work by absorbing ultraviolet (UV) light and re-emitting it as visible blue light, a phenomenon known as fluorescence. This process compensates for the natural yellowing of materials over time, making them appear whiter and more vibrant.
The molecular structure of optical brighteners is characterized by the presence of conjugated double bonds and aromatic rings, which are essential for their ability to absorb UV light. Common functional groups found in optical brighteners include:
1. Stilbene: One of the most widely used classes of optical brighteners, stilbenes have a central benzene ring with two phenyl groups attached. The conjugated system of double bonds allows for efficient absorption of UV light.
The specific arrangement of these functional groups determines the wavelength of light absorbed and emitted by the optical brightener. For example, stilbene-based brighteners typically absorb UV light in the range of 340-360 nm and emit visible blue light at around 420-470 nm.
3. Emission: As the electrons return to their ground state, they release energy in the form of visible blue light. This light is emitted at a longer wavelength than the absorbed UV light, making the material appear whiter and brighter to the human eye.
There are numerous types of optical brighteners, each with its own unique properties and applications. Some of the most common types include:
Each type of optical brightener has its own advantages and limitations, making them suitable for different applications. For instance, water-soluble brighteners are ideal for use in laundry detergents, while oil-soluble brighteners are better suited for textile treatments.
Bleach is a versatile chemical solution used primarily for disinfection, stain removal, and whitening. The most common form of bleach is sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl), but other forms, such as hydrogen peroxide and chlorine dioxide, are also used in various applications. Understanding the chemistry of bleach is essential for grasping its effectiveness and potential risks.
Sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) is the primary active ingredient in household bleach. It is a strong oxidizing agent that works by breaking down organic compounds through a series of chemical reactions. The chemical formula for sodium hypochlorite is NaOCl, and it is typically sold as a 5-6% aqueous solution. Other common forms of bleach include:
2. Chlorine Dioxide (ClO₂): A potent disinfectant and bleaching agent used in water treatment and food processing. It is more stable and less reactive than chlorine gas.
3. Calcium Hypochlorite (Ca(OCl)₂): A solid form of bleach used in swimming pool maintenance and water treatment. It is more concentrated than sodium hypochlorite and releases chlorine upon dissolution in water.
Understanding the chemistry of bleach is crucial for its safe and effective use in various applications. Whether in household cleaning, industrial processes, or water treatment, the right choice of bleach can make a significant difference in achieving the desired results.
Optical brighteners, or fluorescent whitening agents (FWAs), are widely used across various industries due to their ability to enhance the brightness and whiteness of materials. Their applications span from consumer goods to industrial processes, making them indispensable in many sectors.
In the textile industry, optical brighteners play a crucial role in improving the appearance of fabrics. They are added to dyes and finishes to counteract the natural yellowing that occurs over time, making the fabrics appear whiter and more vibrant. The most common types of optical brighteners used in textiles are stilbene derivatives, which are effective in both synthetic and natural fibers.
1. Dyeing and Finishing: Optical brighteners are often incorporated into dye formulations to enhance the color intensity and brightness of the fabric. They can be applied during the dyeing process or as a post-treatment step.
2. Washing and Care: Many laundry detergents contain optical brighteners to keep clothes looking fresh and clean. These brighteners adhere to the fabric and continue to fluoresce even after multiple washes, maintaining the whiteness and brightness of the garments.
The paper industry is another major user of optical brighteners. These chemicals are used to improve the visual appeal of paper products, making them appear whiter and more appealing to consumers. Optical brighteners are particularly useful in the production of high-quality paper, such as office paper, magazine paper, and packaging materials.
1. Papermaking: Optical brighteners are added to the pulp during the papermaking process to enhance the whiteness of the final product. They are especially effective in counteracting the yellowing caused by lignin, a natural component of wood pulp.
2. Coatings and Finishes: In addition to the paper itself, optical brighteners can be used in coatings and finishes applied to the surface of the paper. This not only improves the whiteness but also enhances the printability and overall quality of the paper.
The plastics industry uses optical brighteners to improve the appearance of plastic products. These chemicals can be added to the raw materials during the manufacturing process to create a brighter, more attractive final product. Optical brighteners are particularly useful in applications where aesthetics are important, such as in consumer goods, automotive parts, and packaging.
1. Raw Material Additives: Optical brighteners are often added to the polymer matrix during the extrusion or molding process. This ensures that the brightening effect is uniform throughout the product.
2. Surface Treatments: In some cases, optical brighteners are applied as a surface treatment to existing plastic products. This can be done through spraying, dipping, or coating processes, depending on the specific application.
In the detergent industry, optical brighteners are a key component of many laundry detergents and fabric softeners. They help to keep clothes looking fresh and clean by adhering to the fabric and continuing to fluoresce even after multiple washes.
1. Laundry Detergents: Many liquid and powder detergents contain optical brighteners to enhance the whiteness and brightness of clothes. These brighteners are designed to be compatible with a wide range of fabric types and washing conditions.
2. Fabric Softeners: Fabric softeners often include optical brighteners to provide an additional boost to the appearance of fabrics. This not only improves the feel of the fabric but also enhances its visual appeal.
1. Cosmetics and Personal Care: In cosmetics, optical brighteners can be used to enhance the appearance of skin and hair. They are often found in shampoos, conditioners, and skincare products.
2. Paints and Coatings: In the paints and coatings industry, optical brighteners are used to improve the color and appearance of painted surfaces. They can be added to both water-based and solvent-based paints.
The widespread use of optical brighteners and bleach has raised concerns about their environmental impact. Both chemicals can have significant effects on ecosystems and water quality, and understanding these impacts is crucial for promoting sustainable practices.
1. Biodegradability: Many optical brighteners are designed to be stable and resistant to degradation, which can lead to their persistence in the environment. Some studies have shown that certain types of optical brighteners can persist in water bodies for extended periods, potentially accumulating in sediments and aquatic organisms.
2. Bioaccumulation: The persistence of optical brighteners can result in bioaccumulation in the food chain. Aquatic organisms, such as fish and invertebrates, can absorb these chemicals, leading to potential health effects and ecological imbalances.
1. Aquatic Life: Optical brighteners can be toxic to aquatic organisms at certain concentrations. Studies have shown that exposure to high levels of optical brighteners can affect the growth, reproduction, and survival of fish and other aquatic life.
2. Human Health: While the direct toxicity of optical brighteners to humans is generally low, there are concerns about their potential long-term effects. Some research suggests that prolonged exposure to optical brighteners may cause skin irritation and allergic reactions in sensitive individuals.
Nutrient Release: The breakdown of optical brighteners in water can release nutrients, contributing to eutrophication. Eutrophication is a process where excessive nutrients in water bodies lead to algal blooms, which can deplete oxygen levels and harm aquatic ecosystems.
1. Aquatic Life: Sodium hypochlorite, the most common form of bleach, is highly toxic to aquatic organisms. Even at low concentrations, bleach can be lethal to fish, invertebrates, and other aquatic life. The release of bleach into water bodies can have severe ecological consequences.
2. Human Health: Exposure to bleach can cause respiratory issues, skin irritation, and eye damage. Inhaling bleach fumes, especially in enclosed spaces, can be particularly harmful. Accidental ingestion of bleach can lead to serious health problems, including burns to the mouth and throat, and gastrointestinal issues.
1. Formation of Disinfection Byproducts (DBPs): When bleach is used in water treatment, it can react with organic matter to form disinfection byproducts (DBPs), such as trihalomethanes (THMs) and haloacetic acids (HAAs). These compounds are known to be carcinogenic and can pose long-term health risks to humans.
2. Environmental Persistence: Chlorine compounds can persist in the environment and accumulate in soil and water. This can lead to the formation of chlorinated organic compounds, which are difficult to degrade and can have long-lasting ecological impacts.
Link to Ogilvy
1. Consumer Awareness: Educating consumers about the environmental impact of these chemicals can encourage more responsible usage. Simple changes, such as using eco-friendly detergents and reducing the frequency of bleach use, can make a significant difference.
1. Eco-Friendly Alternatives: Developing and promoting eco-friendly alternatives to optical brighteners and bleach can reduce their environmental impact. For example, using plant-based brighteners and natural disinfectants like vinegar and baking soda can be effective and safer options.
2. Biodegradable Formulations: Research into biodegradable optical brighteners and bleach alternatives is ongoing. These formulations can break down more easily in the environment, reducing the risk of long-term ecological damage.
1. Environmental Regulations: Governments can implement regulations to control the use and disposal of optical brighteners and bleach. Setting limits on the concentration of these chemicals in products and requiring proper disposal methods can help protect the environment.
2. Eye Protection: If optical brighteners come into contact with the eyes, they can cause irritation and discomfort. It is important to wear appropriate eye protection, such as safety goggles, when handling these chemicals.
Vapor Inhalation: Some optical brighteners can release vapors that may be harmful if inhaled. Ensure adequate ventilation in areas where optical brighteners are used, and consider wearing a respirator if necessary.
1. Temperature and Light Sensitivity: Optical brighteners can degrade when exposed to high temperatures or direct sunlight. Store them in a cool, dry place away from heat sources and light.
Proper Disposal: Follow local regulations for the disposal of optical brighteners. Do not pour them down drains or into water bodies. Dispose of them according to the manufacturer's instructions or through approved waste management facilities.
1. Burns and Irritation: Bleach is a strong irritant and can cause burns and severe irritation to the skin and eyes. Always wear gloves and protective eyewear when handling bleach.
2. First Aid: If bleach comes into contact with the skin, rinse the affected area thoroughly with water for at least 15 minutes. If it gets into the eyes, flush the eyes with water for at least 15 minutes and seek medical attention immediately.
1. Fumes: Inhaling bleach fumes can cause respiratory issues, including coughing, shortness of breath, and irritation of the nose and throat. Use bleach in well-ventilated areas and avoid mixing it with other chemicals, especially ammonia, as this can produce toxic gases.
2. Respiratory Protection: Consider wearing a respirator in enclosed spaces or when using large quantities of bleach.
1. Toxicity: Accidental ingestion of bleach can be extremely dangerous, causing burns to the mouth, throat, and stomach. If ingested, do not induce vomiting; instead, drink plenty of water and seek immediate medical attention.
1. Labeling: Clearly label all containers of bleach to avoid confusion. Store bleach in a secure, child-proof location to prevent accidental ingestion.
1. Proper Disposal: Follow local regulations for the disposal of bleach. Dilute small amounts of bleach with water and pour it down the drain with running water. For larger quantities, follow the manufacturer's instructions or consult with local waste management authorities.
Optical brighteners and bleach are both essential chemicals with a wide range of applications, from enhancing the appearance of materials to ensuring hygiene and cleanliness. While they share the goal of improving the visual and functional qualities of products, they operate through fundamentally different mechanisms. Optical brighteners achieve their effects through fluorescence, absorbing UV light and re-emitting it as visible blue light, while bleach works through oxidation, breaking down organic compounds.
Understanding the chemistry, applications, environmental impact, and safety considerations of these chemicals is crucial for their effective and responsible use. By following best practices and adopting sustainable alternatives, we can minimize their environmental footprint and ensure the safety of users. Whether in the textile, paper, plastics, or detergent industries, the judicious use of optical brighteners and bleach can contribute to a cleaner, brighter, and more sustainable world.
Because the natural colour of the alpha cellulose and cotton linters from which paper is made is not pure white, all papers that claim to be white must have optical brighteners in their coatings. According to leading paper manufacturer, Hahnemuhle, it is impossible to produce pure white papers without adding optical brighteners because the natural whiteness of alpha cellulose tops out at 95%, while the natural whiteness of cotton linters is only 90%.
Although many photographers prefer to print on bright white papers, there are both advantages and disadvantages in using papers that contain optical brighteners. But information on OBAs is not readily available. Many companies that distribute inkjet papers are reluctant to reveal which papers in their ranges are OBA-free or even which have low OBA levels.
Photographers, however, need to be able to identify which papers contain OBAs and which are OBA-free so they can choose which type of paper to use for different applications. Making an inappropriate choice could be costly and time-consuming.
One distinct advantage of papers containing OBAs is that a bright white paper base will allow the maximum colour gamut and black density of the printed image to be reproduced. However, on the negative side, the chemicals used in the OBAs can affect the integrity and longevity of a fine art print over time.
OBA Stability
All UV brighteners are inherently unstable chemicals. In the process of fluorescence, the absorption of a photon (elementary particle of light) triggers the emission of another photon with a longer wavelength. In the case of the OBAs used in inkjet papers, this emission is at the blue end of the visible spectrum. This transfer of energy comes at a cost: slow changes in the fluorescent chemicals.
As these chemicals break down, their ability to fluoresce deteriorates until, eventually, they will no longer do so. When this happens, the colour of the paper will revert to its normal creamy or yellowish hue. How long this process takes will depend on how much exposure the paper has to UV light and the ambient temperatures the prints are displayed in. According to independent media tester, Wilhelm Imaging Research, OBAs ‘may lose activity when subjected to high temperatures in accelerated thermal aging tests and, it may be assumed, in long-term storage in albums or other dark places under normal room temperature conditions’.
The effect on image quality will depend on the amount of optical brighteners in the paper coating as well as the lighting the print is displayed in. Prints that are illuminated by direct or indirect daylight (which has a high UV component) will be affected sooner than prints displayed under incandescent tungsten illumination (where the UV component is low or negligible).
As OBAs decompose they may also cause yellow stains to appear on prints. Post-printing protective coatings have been developed to reduce the effect of UV exposure of inkjet prints. However, their effectiveness has yet to be proven. Some can also change the appearance of the surface of prints. UV-blocking glass can also slow down the degradation of OBA additives but, at the same time, they will also reduce the level of fluorescence and, consequently the brightening effect of the OBAs.
Metamerism
The term ‘metamerism’ refers to the difference in the appearance of prints under different types of lighting. It’s a serious problem for print-makers who use papers with OBAs because the colour of the paper base is so directly connected to the lighting under which it is displayed.
You can test this phenomenon by making two prints of the same image, one on a paper with OBAs and one without. Take both prints outdoors and observe their appearance under normal daylight. The paper with the OBAs should look extremely white, while the paper without them will look creamy. Now, take the prints indoors where they are exposed to neither sunlight nor artificial lighting and observe the whiteness. You probably will not be able to see a difference between the two.
Prints made on paper with and without OBAs will usually look the same under incandescent lighting, because of its low UV content. Since the OBAs can no longer fluoresce, the base colour of the paper will will show through and make the paper appear as creamy as the base colour of papers without OBAs.
Metamerism has serious consequences for your digital printing because it adds an uncertainty to the printing process. When you profile a printing paper, the ‘white point’ of the paper substrate is an integral component of the profile’s accuracy. If the whiteness of your paper changes, so must your profile.
The best way to avoid problems with metamerism is to install a viewing ‘box’ with standardised lighting and use it whenever you need to check print colours. (An alternative option is to view prints under the same type of lighting in which they will be displayed.)
Your Choice
The decision about whether to use inkjet papers with optical brighteners is entirely at the photographer’s discretion. Some images will look best on a bright, white paper, while others could be subtly improved by printing them on a slightly creamy paper. For many images, there is little difference in the overall look of the print, regardless of which base colour is used. This is particularly true for prints that are displayed in lighting with minimal UV content.
If you like the look of the bright white paper and your prints are not being made for extended display periods, there’s no real reason not to use papers containing OBAs. All leading paper manufacturers have papers with and without OBAs in their portfolios and many manufacturers have products with very low OBA levels. In theory, it should be relatively easy to find the type of paper you want for different applications.
However, professional wedding and portrait photographers should be wary of papers with OBAs if they expect to obtain orders for reprints several months after a wedding or portrait shoot. Because the original paper and profile will no longer produce a true match of the original print, making reprints that match the client’s original can be extremely difficult and costly.
It is also wise to ask clients about how they plan to display enlargements before prints are made and take the type of lighting into consideration. Fluorescent lighting will maximise the effect of optical brighteners but may also have some metameric effects on certain colours. Incandescent and halogen lighting will do little to stimulate the OBAs and will usually give a ‘warm’ overall appearance that may even emphasise the colours on OBA-free papers.
For photographers who make prints for exhibitions or for long-term archiving, it is probably best to avoid papers with OBAs or, at least use papers with low OBA levels, such as most Canson papers and Hahnemuehle Photo Rag. However, the best advice comes from Henry Wilhelm, who states: “When long-term image permanence is of critical importance with museum fine-art collections, for example papers with fluorescent brighteners should be avoided where possible.”
Papers without OBAs:
Awagami Washi papers
Canson Infinity Aquarelle Rag
Canson Infinity Edition Etching Rag
Canson Infinity Platine Fibre Rag
Canson Infinity Rag Photographique
Canson PhotoSatin
Canson PrintMaKing
Canson Velin Museum Rag
Epson Cold Press Natural
Epson Hot Press Natural
Epson Legacy Fibre
Epson Legacy Platine
Epson’s Ultrasmooth Fine Art Paper
Ilford Galerie Gold Cotton (Smooth, Textured)
Breathing Color’s Sterling Rag 210
Breathing Color Chromata White
Breathing Colour Sterling Rag 210
Crane Museo MAX
Crane Museo Silver Rag
Crane Museo Portfolio Rag
Epson Ultra Premium Photo Paper Glossy
Epson Premium Photo Paper Glossy
Epson UltraSmooth Fine Art Paper
Hahnemuhle Bamboo Fine Art
Hahnemuhle FineArt Baryta
Hahnemuhle Photo Art
Hahnemuhle Photo Rag Baryta
Hahnemuhle Photo Rag Pearl
Hahnemühle Rice Paper 100
Hahnemuhle Museum Etching
Hahnemuhle Natural Art Duo
Hahnemuhle Photo Rag Metallic
Inkjet Pro Elite (Lightly & Highly Textured)
Moab Colorado Fiber Gloss
Moab Entrada Bright
Moab Entrada Natural
Moab Juniper Baryta Rag
Moab Lasal Matt Archival
Moab Slickrock Metallic (Pearl & Silver)
Permajet Classic FineArt Artist Classic
Permajet ImageLife Alpha
Permajet ImageLife Delta Matt Fibre
Papers with OBAs:
Epson Hot Press Bright
Epson Cold Press Bright
Epson Legacy Baryta (minimal OBAs)
Canson Infinity Baryta Photographique (minimal OBAs)
Canson Infinity Baryta Prestige (minimal OBAs)
Canson Photo Premium RC (HighGloss, Gloss, Satin and Lustre surfaces)
PermaJet Gloss
PermaJet Oyster
PermaJet Smooth Pearl
PermaJet Smooth Gloss
PermaJet Titanium Lustre
PermaJet Ultra Pearl
PermaJet Photo Lustre
PermaJet MattPlus
Want more information on Optical Brightener OB? Feel free to contact us.